1851
Robert
Cochran
1852
Robert
Cochran
1853
Thomas
Clark
1854
Daniel
C. Wheeler
1855
Hiram
Harriman
1856
Daniel
H. Currier
1857
Washington
George
1858
Washington
George
1859
David
C. Webster
1860
Seth
Doton
1861
Washington
George
1862
Washington
George
1863
Washington
George
1864
Daniel
H. Currier
1865
Daniel
H. Currier
1866
Washington
George
1867
John
G. Langdon
1868
Alexander
G. Smythe
1869
Alexander
G. Smythe
1870
Alexander
G. Smythe
1871
Alexander
G. Smythe
1872
Cyrus
Keniston
1873
Cyrus
Keniston
1874
Cyrus
Keniston
1875
Alexander
G. Smythe
1876
Alexander
G. Smythe
1877
Alexander
G. Smythe
1878
Lucius
M. Howe
1879
Lucius
M. Howe
1880
John
Mason
1881
John
Mason
1882
Renselear
O. Wright
1883
Renselear
O. Wright **
1884
Joseph
M. Howe
1885
Joseph
M. Howe
1886
Charles
J. Gould
1887
Hiram
Clark
1888
Hiram
Clark
1889
Hiram
Clark
1890
Hiram
Clark
1891
Hiram
Clark
1892
Hiram
Clark
1893
Hiram
Clark
1894
Hiram
Clark
1895
Frank
C. Calley
1896
Frank
C. Calley
1897
Frank
C. Calley
1898
David
H. Hallenbeck
1899
Edward
A. Chase
1900
Edward
A. Chase
1901
Edward
A. Chase
1902
William
A. Kimball
1903
William
A. Kimball
1904
William
A. Kimball
1905
William
A. Kimball
** Renselear O. Wright died October 24, 1883 and Joseph
M. Howe was appointed October 29, 1883.
The above information was taken from Volume I of Stearns
History of Plymouth, published in 1905.